[sock411]

very interseting suggestion i like the minigame and the map its really
fascanating lol

[Patben]

Thanks everyone for your support!

[Saphi]

I actually posted a few suggestions on your other thread. I think one of them was to situate some of the features outside the guild so as to prevent leveling of the other skills e.g. fletching and firemaking from being too easy. Another question is: Do you still get ashes from the incinerator? Cos if i'm not mistaken, members use ashes in herblore....

[Maxman]

I love it! This suggestion could actually work even though it's been suggest a billion times. I'm sure (they better) Jagex will make one in the near future.

~Max

[Patben]

Saphi, on Feb 18 2008, 03:35 AM, said:

I actually posted a few suggestions on your other thread. I think one of them was to situate some of the features outside the guild so as to prevent leveling of the other skills e.g. fletching and firemaking from being too easy. Another question is: Do you still get ashes from the incinerator? Cos if i'm not mistaken, members use ashes in herblore....

A little bin you have to empty of ashes every once in a while???

Wow, thanks everyone for your support!

[darth4knight4]

I love the idea and think its great, especially since all i do is woodcutting, but I think it should be accessable to f2p...

[Conqueror]

I really do like this idea a lot. Personally I think Karamja is the best choice as far as location goes, although Fremennik Province could be used as well. I like the fact that the requirement is fairly high, as well as the guild has benefits for Firemakers and Fletchers alike. You've put a fair amount of effort into thinking about bonuses with regards to the statues as well. A great suggestion and one of the better ones I've seen - Kudos.

[MedievalEscaper]

Awesome idea! I think the requirement should be 1 million experience in woodcutting or 75 woodcutting. Otherwise... totally radical!

[Patben]

Wow, i never though this topic would be so popular!

Thanks for the support everyone! OVER 1K VIEWS!

[Mike]

As stated in your other topic:

Quote

As much as the thought of a guild for advanced lumberjacks thrills me, I see no point to it. The abundance of trees in RuneScape makes the Woodcutting skill unmatched in places to train. You can go anywhere in RuneScape and find the tree you want near a bank, or just a tree to cut and burn. A Woodcutting Guild is just one of those things we don't really need.

~Mike

~Mike

[Patben]

Quote

Quote

As much as the thought of a guild for advanced lumberjacks thrills me, I see no point to it. The abundance of trees in RuneScape makes the Woodcutting skill unmatched in places to train. You can go anywhere in RuneScape and find the tree you want near a bank, or just a tree to cut and burn. A Woodcutting Guild is just one of those things we don't really need.

~Mike

Thanks for your input

Also as stated in my other topic.

[commando1213]

is this F2p or P2P? if you make it F2p you could put it North East of lumby castle cuz thers already a yew tree there, and you can put it by that pond where the willows grow about halfway to draynor.

[Saphi]

commando1213, on Feb 19 2008, 08:55 PM, said:

is this F2p or P2P? if you make it F2p you could put it North East of lumby castle cuz thers already a yew tree there, and you can put it by that pond where the willows grow about halfway to draynor.

Isn't the space there a wee bit tiny for a guild?

[Patben]

commando1213, on Feb 19 2008, 06:55 AM, said:

is this F2p or P2P? if you make it F2p you could put it North East of lumby castle cuz thers already a yew tree there, and you can put it by that pond where the willows grow about halfway to draynor.

I also don't think Jagex will go for a F2P update...

[HDBalab]

I think it's an amazing idea, the fletching \ woodcutting guild has been long awaited. However, I have a suggestion. 80 woodcutting is ridiculously easy, in fact over 150 thousand players have it. That would be one crowded guild..My suggestion is a less round number first, like 88. Also, I think that the player should have to have 88 woodcutting, firemaking annnd fletching. This would round the number down by aloot, making it much more of an elite guild, instead of a joke like all the others.

I also think a cool spot for it would be either,

A) ape aptoll, would slim the number of people cutting there eveen more, and would make it so you also need to do a few hard quests.

B) a little extravagant, but underwater maybe? south of castle wars still, but just make a tunnel going under there. The excuse would be that the water makes the trees grow much better.

[Patben]

Smokekill1, on Feb 19 2008, 04:20 PM, said:

I think it's an amazing idea, the fletching \ woodcutting guild has been long awaited. However, I have a suggestion. 80 woodcutting is ridiculously easy, in fact over 150 thousand players have it. That would be one crowded guild..My suggestion is a less round number first, like 88. Also, I think that the player should have to have 88 woodcutting, firemaking annnd fletching. This would round the number down by aloot, making it much more of an elite guild, instead of a joke like all the others.

I agree with what you say - Fletch and Firemaking requirements are a good idea. 88 Firemaking...errr?? Kinda high, wouldnt you say? Though i applaud the idea. Thanks!

[HDBalab]

A little high, but why would you want random people, who barely even WC or firemake to go in there. It would make it so you could have even more of those magic trees, and make it a real special treat to get in there..not something you just happen to get. I mean how many people work to get into the magic guild? The cooking guild? No one, because the req's are a joke.

[Patben]

Smokekill1, on Feb 19 2008, 04:26 PM, said:

A little high, but why would you want random people, who barely even WC or firemake to go in there. It would make it so you could have even more of those magic trees, and make it a real special treat to get in there..not something you just happen to get. I mean how many people work to get into the magic guild? The cooking guild? No one, because the req's are a joke.

How about something like 88 Woodcutting, 80 Fletching, 70-77 Firemaking?

[alexihuerta]

like the idea i love it 10/10 or 5/5

my 2 suggestions and 1 question..

1.- suggestion : you should make a credit part like example:

6.0.- credit list ~.^

2.- suggestion : the wc master should be there =]

and my question is

what kind of mini-game is there? i was thinking in one like this :

who ever cuts first alot of trees in 1 minute wins :P

well those are my suggestions and questions

NOTE and EDIT: ME as f2p i think it should stay in a p2p place.. since jagex wont go for f2p stuff..

it hurts me :P but, its the truth..

~alexihuerta

P.S make the credit's list please! :P

This post has been edited by alexihuerta: 19 February 2008 - 06:07 PM

[Patben]

alexihuerta, on Feb 19 2008, 06:05 PM, said:

like the idea i love it 10/10 or 5/5

my 2 suggestions and 1 question..

1.- suggestion : you should make a credit part like example:

6.0.- credit list ~.^

2.- suggestion : the wc master should be there =]

and my question is

what kind of mini-game is there? i was thinking in one like this :

who ever cuts first alot of trees in 1 minute wins :P

well those are my suggestions and questions

NOTE and EDIT: ME as f2p i think it should stay in a p2p place.. since jagex wont go for f2p stuff..

it hurts me :P but, its the truth..

~alexihuerta

P.S make the credit's list please! :P

Ummm...Yeah, that mini-game: not so great . The Woodcutting Tutor probably won't move from Lumby, but you never know. And a credit's list....too much hassle