The following is used from Tip.It

All damage calculations were done Nude, using Super Strength, 99 Strength, Aggressive and Piety.

The evaluation of what is essentially the top 3 weapons in RS.

Chaotic Longsword

Max of 456

Speed of 5

Stab of 107

Slash of 124

Defender Adds

Max of 13

20 Stab

19 Slash

Compared against Godsword

Godsword

Max of 486

Speed of 4

Slash of 132

Crush of 80

Extra: Has potentially useful/stronger special

Winner: Armadyl/Bandos Godsword, Otherwise, use the Longsword for Speed and Accuracy with a defender.

Chaotic Rapier

Max of 412

Speed of 6

Compared against Abyssal Whip

Abyssal Whip

Max of 363

Speed of 6

Extra: Has a special to increase accuracy

Downfalls: No strength option, special's not exactly useful

Winner: Chaotic Rapier

Chaotic Maul

Max of 542

Speed of 3

Compared against EVERY Speed 3 weapon

The next closest is Dharok's Axe

Max of 420

Speed of 3

Winner, by a longshot: Chaotic Maul

Notes: All chaotic weapons require a 2m repair cost after 10 hours of combat. Still, much cheaper than replacing your VLS. I also expect that because of the high skill requirements and the difficulty required in getting the chaotic weapons, that they would have a high protect value, comparable to a godsword. Also realize that these weapons do not have specials, and most would consider switching down to say a DDS or a D Mace would be a downgrade, even with the special. I personally plan to use Morrigan's Javelins as my special weapon when I get my Chaotic Rapier.

Edit: Or Possibly Seercull to disable their Vengeance.

Hope I've enlightened you, and encouraged you to skill those Dungeons.

**Edited by Pixelz, 16 April 2010 - 09:40 PM.**