[Lordaron8]

If you wanted to just hangout.. Couldn't you just do it in a clan member's poh? I don't see much of a difference between clan houses and a normal poh except for the events portal, which would be abused and the clan bank, which is still flawed. It sounds like a fun idea at first, but I doubt clans would use the houses much except right after the release.

[hTs]

This would be a neat updated in general, specifically for smaller, community clans, but I'm not sure if top warring clans would take much use to it. The majority of top clans ONLY war, with optional side events such as God Wars and Dking. This update would implement a lot towards smaller clans who are maybe more interested in the roleplaying side of the game versus clan warring.

I'm not sure if the bank system would be put to use, but I could realistically see top clans putting all their Rune in and creating a massive supply inventory. The practice arena I like, and see potential for a number of different uses. Small clans could use it to build their skills, medium sized clans could work on developing their skills, and top clans could use the space to go over and work out small kinks they may have within their warring performance.

[Arno]

Coming from an Events Leader, I can tell you that I would very much like such a HQ. It seems like a very good idea, and also a very plausible one. The only thing I can see become a problem is the clan bank addition. It would probably be abused by RWT'ers.

[Slaywulf21]

Devin, on 09 November 2009 - 10:13 PM, said:

I love this suggestion. Opposed to another poster above, I love to just sit and hang around RuneScape. Finally clans can have an official spot to do just that.

In regards to the clan bank and purchases, perhaps all of (or just a majority) the clan members have to vote on large purchases, so that the leader cannot just use the money to buy random items. Even more, there could be toggle settings (again, by a vote) that allow the bank to be a free communal bank. Everyone can put money in and the leader(s) can then make the purchases. Anyone who has access to the bank can remove whatever they need, though it could be proportional to the amount you put in, and it would have limits. I've almost imagined a system where the clan works as it's own little entity; the supplies of one are the supplies of all.

All in all, this is a step up from the usual clan-house suggestions, so for that I commend you.

I totally agree, this would be a great place and an awesome place to hang out with your frinnds!

[GohankutenMD]

T R Gaz, on 12 November 2009 - 02:21 AM, said:

Goyatuzo, on 12 November 2009 - 03:34 AM, said:

T R Gaz, on 10 November 2009 - 02:21 AM, said:

Hail, on 10 November 2009 - 01:26 AM, said:

Shadowryudo, on 09 November 2009 - 07:21 PM, said:

Basicaly, this is never going to work. Clans who partake in fights use G.E for supplies and thats all thats needed

As for having a "place to hang", who really sits around on RS for a long period of time doing nothing? To be honest im pretty sure everyone would rather train or make money if they are in a clan then jsut sit around doing nothing. Clan chat or irc is for those who wish to talk tbh :/

The basis of this is "We already have some minor things - we should have to have places where people can do things more conveniently", and that anti-motivational attitude pretty much ruins the point of having a suggestion in the first place, so I don't see your point. (We have PvP Worlds, so why should more PvP set-ups be implemented? We have mini-games, so what's the point of implementing more?, etc. are pretty good comparisons to your post.)

Useful things like pvp items, worlds etc are great, but really what im getting at it...with the "clan portal", clan bank and just generaly standing around in the clan house, people except for under established clans wouldnt use them. Most people are busy training or making money or pking.

I dont have the attitude you stated, im simply saying this idea is not that great as i highly doubt anyone other then those level 50's that think theyre a clan would use them after the first week of release.

Did I misinterpret your statement or are you saying there's no point to this suggestion except for people that are in the clan?

If that is what you meant, then I don't see the problem. Since it is a CLAN house, the general public should not be able to access it. I'm sure this house can be accessed by anybody within the clan the house was built for at any given time. If it can't, then what would the point of this suggestion be?

If it's based on the fact you're going to be bored doing nothing, then simply more rooms can be added. A clan animal zoo (monster zoo to kill monsters) can be added later for an optional room that can be bought, and other rooms can be bought. The idea for this suggestion is to encourage inter-clan relations by donating and helping each other out. I have the same disbelief in the clan bank system as you because there just isn't enough incentive to donate to the bank when you can be making so much more money by selling the same items in the Grand Exchange.

Basicaly, what im saying is that this suggestion would only be popular for about 2 weeks if implimented into the game...Then the majourity of the clan world would forget about it as theres nothing to do there that they could do from their normal training monsters. "Clan Houses" have been suggested for quite some time from multiple people in the past few years, and each time its been pointed out that the idea is flawed as i doubt hardly anyone escept the small clans who dont know what to do will use it.

That is where you are wrong. A lot of major clans would use this as the massing spot if allowed to f2p. It has a bank really close and only those in the clan can get in so means you're options can't be spied on before the war. And with a teleport to clan wars arena would make it really easy to get everyone there. Also clans would use this as a place to hold parties. And for clans going for pvp this would be a good place to mass without other clans knowing and then using the clan wars arena teleport makes a fast teleport from a safe area to another safe area that is in wild.