[Capptain]

BH is more profitible with 100% chance of loot but, you have to get out of penalties.

I liked bh more.

[nhp]

Well Jagex made Pvp worlds for one reason. That was for killing people who was cutting your tree or stealing your ores.

[Mog Time]

Bh is better for profit, however don't forgot those pen's. Sometimes you lose the loot, or can't find it.
Pking is funner.

[daniel987600]

I think that bounty hunter is now gets me more money than PvP because with bounty hunter, I actually get items that a person
dropped, instead of a predetermined item by JaGeX, and the items that are dropped are usually much better than the predetermined item.
(I have gotten 23 abby whips with BH, but none with Pk).

Daniel987600

[Skill Aid]

Both suck in my opinion. Even with top notch gear and 99 combat stats, I can't kill worth crud. Infact, I've never gotten a good kill in either. Waste of money for em both. I make more money in a day than 90% of people do pk'ing. The major point is, if you can get really lucky and get a good hit in pvp or bh, you'll be successful. But you need luck! Many people don't have luck, like myself. So good ole dragons and aviansies will work. After all, who can say 3-5m a day off killing easy monsters is bad?

[Devin]

I would say BH because you can pick out a target to hunt down. There isn't any waiting for hours trying to get a good drop.

[Shin0]

Bh no doubt except pens suck and gettin 55 d bolt specced all the dam time sucks too

[Deus]

Their's two answers.

Bounty Hunter is more profitable however both are a waste of money either way ;P

[Piyrw]

I would say Bounty Hunter, because you get their stuff, as compared to PvP, you get whatever Runescape decides you get.

[lBRADl]

If you're soloing, I would say that PvP is more profitable. If you're in a big clan, Bh is more profitable.
I voted for PvP since I am not in a clan.

[Kg owns you]

All i can say is,

When i kill full sara, I WANT full sara. Not a rune mace. BH 4ever

[Andrieux]

Nulled my vote because Bounty Hunter is PvP...as is PKing, Castle Wars, and other things.

[«RaSCaL»]

As a clannie, i find PvP more a source of fun rather than profitability. Sure you get kills now and then and you could "hope" for corrupted dragon items, but Bounty Hunter is designed for dm's and such and several people dm in Rune (t) and so on..

The risk is obviously always present, but dm'ing is like gambling, you cant determine a win/loss.

[Buzz™]

Bh is more profitable

[àñtí JõKèR]

You cant even compare the two, in bh you drop some1 you get all there stuff but theres a slide ..pen

in pvp if you drop some1 theres a slide, if u have no dp chances u gettin something good is very low
ive droped prolly like 100M+ worth of gear in pvp and gotten prolly not even 1m in drops from that 100m worth of kills

overall bh is obviously more profitable, if you know what your doing and what not, but if you 26k in pvp you can argue and say its more profitable. its really all based on luck.

[Spank]

I was so pissed when they took out old wildy, and replaced with BH, but then i got use to it and said "alright, still a little unfair level wise but meh " I didn't think jagex could screw it up anymore than it was, but low and behold PvP Then they took out BH and replaced it for....PvP? Random Drops? Fun?? I had a WTH moment when that happened, because Pking was always seen as a primary source of income, and i could guarantee making money back(more) when i killed someone. Now, I can't...at all. This random loot might be fun for a little while, until you start realizing your not making money off it anymore. Like i've said in other post, I want what i killed for. Mystic top off of Full Bandos and Dclaws? WTH is that?

This post has been edited by Spank: 26 January 2010 - 05:20 PM